Disagreement Over Smoothies
Steve and I have a disagreement over smoothies. He feels they should be 60% fruit and 40% veggies. He’s taken that straight from one book on smoothies. However, I have found that having the smoothie in the morning with that much fruit is not working for me. It makes me feel light headed and not good a little while after drinking it, and that brings me to another book that recommends using mostly greens and trying not to have too much fruit in the mix. Beyond that, when we were at a talk given by Steven Fowkes, who is a molecular biologist (www.ceri.com), he strongly suggested that people have to follow their own metabolism, and that for him, fruit in the morning is absolutely not appropriate. According to each of our own unique systems, we need to find out what works to make the body hum. What is just right at noon may not be appropriate at 8 AM, while for someone else, the opposite holds true.
This whole process shows us how important it is to not be fanatical, and not to get caught in the trap of believing that one size fits all. I’m off now to see if making a green smoothie with veggies and perhaps one small chunk of banana will be the right thing for me. If not, maybe I have to eat something first and then have a smoothie later in the day. It is an experimentation in process! (KJ)
————————————————-
Update by Steve
I went to get a haircut this morning while Kathleen was left to her own devices. She would not drink my beautiful delicious Green Smoothie this morning because she protested that I made them with too much fruit. Today I made mine with Mango, Pineapple, Orange, Banana, Baby Spinach and a large leaf of Mustard Greens. Yuuuuummmmm! Beware of mustard greens because they are very peppery and tangy and spicey!
Kathleen’s smoothie was made with spinach, mustard greens, ginger, mint, 2 carrots and parsley.
I took photos of the results for your edification.
Note: She said she drank a glassful and had a hard time not upchucking it. I took one sip of hers and nearly gagged. So there you have it, the disagreement resolved!
Explore posts in the same categories: Green Smoothie Experiments, green smoothies, Raw Food, smoothiesTags: Green Smoothie Experiment, green smoothies
You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.


March 6, 2010 at 5:09 pm
Fruit is very sweet, so it makes me feel light-headed but I don’t think the veggie smoothies taste very nice… Still, they’re both just as good for you!
Ciao
http://scarletsculturegarden.wordpress.com
March 6, 2010 at 6:26 pm
I noticed that in Steve’s recipe for his “best smoothie ever!” it was mostly fruit with a small amount of spinach. Unless he forgot to type something I thought it was heavy on the fruit.
I suggest that you start blending the veggies first, then add fruit “to taste”. Pour Kathleen’s into a glass first, then Steve can add more fruit “to taste” as he wishes. Both will be happy campers!
Nancy
March 6, 2010 at 7:35 pm
Okay…so mia culpa, mia culpa! I made my “own” smoothie with no fruit, and egad!!!! I drank it down, feeling very self-righteous, and after about 2 minutes, my stomach was gurgling and I felt like I was going to be sick. I drank lots of water to dilute the sludge…hahahaha….and finally things calmed down. So I made a cup of tea, had a zucchini,onion, green bell pepper one egg scramble, and I felt human again.
I think I’ll start drinking smoothies (Steve’s kind) in the late morning after I’ve eaten something.
March 6, 2010 at 11:10 pm
Keep in mind that carrots are very high on the glycemic index, so you might cut back on those, too.
March 7, 2010 at 12:46 am
Very amused, I am charmed and smiling in regards to the conversation between the two of you. One has the “the ONE book”… the other has photos as definitive proof! Many thanks for sharing your foibles, experimentations and all your successes, recipes and how to’s. Your BLOG is superb!
March 7, 2010 at 1:20 am
Thanks so much. We have a lot of tussling about because we’re both strong willed (LOL…that’s an understatement!) and we have our own ideas about the way to do things, but I have to say…Steve is often right about the ingredients, and he’s such a SUPER chef that almost everything he makes is a winner! (KJ)
November 2, 2011 at 3:49 am
I see bias here. look at how you made her smoothie sloppy on the sides of the glass! lol
I love all veggie smoothies! Just add more carrots and spinach..less mustard greens!